Wednesday, June 14, 2006

فلسفه آموزش

وقت تلف شده اما در مدرسه زیاده،این رو نمی تونم و نمی خوام انکار کنم
ساعت ها و روزها وقت صرف می کنیم و یه نتیجه ای می گیریم که به نظر همه مون آخرشه!و ناگهان تصمیم گیری های مدرسه عوض می شه
و بدتر از اون وقتیه که دور خودمون می چرخیم و می چرخیم
ساعت ها حرف زده ایم،نمی دونم چند نفر ساعت.با هم.با معلم ها،با بچه ها
امروز با دو نفر از بچه ها به این سوال کلی فکر می کردیم:آیا به کسی که نیازی رو هنوز در خودش لمس نکرده،باید چیزی رو یاد داد؟
مثالی می زنم:آیا به بچه نواختن ساز رو یاد بدیم ؟کی؟6 سالگی؟12 سالگی؟وقتی خودش اعلام کرد که من می خواهم ساز بزنم یا خیلی زودتر؟راستی یه آدم کی واقعا نیاز به کلاس زبان حس می کنه؟
شما چی فکر می کنین؟می شه نظری اگه دارین برام بنویسین؟

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

be Adam ya be ma? Look at what we are? Look at what we get from the childhood? Look at our prospects in our lives? Look at our world? Hows? and Whys? Then see if your questions are right or wrong? I believe you have asked the wrong questions in the first place! Change the questions, then you will find the answers yourself.

یاسمن said...

تو دقیقا چی می خواهی بگی س.م.؟می شه بگی اشتباه این سوال کجاست؟من اشتباهی نمی بینم آخه

Anonymous said...

Dear Mr/s M!

I think your logic is impaired by wrong deduction. By your questions you've concluded that it's not right to ask how our children should be treated, according to their demands or by our obligations. Let's have a look to other side: have you ever thought about the reasons that have raised these questions for you? Don't you think that the situation of our current world (whether it's heaven or hell or something between) would be partially explained as a consequence of how the previous generations were trained by their parents (the cycle that continues to the beginning of human history) Don't you think that Yasi's question would be a substantial aspect of such a training? If your answer is positive to these two questions, you would easily understand that you have built up your cause-effect relationship in the wrong order.

Regards,
Payam

P.S. If you believe that our current situation is not fair, don't you think that we should cut this defective cycle somewhere to let future generations not feel the same?

Anonymous said...

Dear Payam,

Thanks for your opinon. I will think about what you said. I don't know why I remember this verse reading your comment, be dar eye ta be beenee.

Yasi, there is performance in Hozeye Andeeshe va Honar, Tallar e andeeshe, opposite to the Amirkabeer Uni. at 5 on this coming Friday. You can get a few tickets calling this no. 44664870
Ask your questions form this expert, Sudabeh Salem.

What I want to say is, you cannot fnd an answer just looking at certain criterias . You have to have a more comprhensive and complete view of education.

یاسمن said...

البته که من باید دید بهتر و دقیق تری داشته باشم!
و بابت کنسرت سودابه سالم هم ممنونم.اتفاقا من هم بلیط دارم

Anonymous said...

Dear M, Thanks for your attention. As a matter of fact, I definitely agree with your suggestion mentioned in the last paragraph of your second comment. However, my problem is to know where the point to begin would be in such a broad approach proposed by you. Actually I've been overwhelmed by such general advices and do need some more clear and detailed words. I really appreciate it if you let me know your point of view in this regard.

P.S.
دستان ِ بسته‌ام آزاد نبود تا هر چشم‌انداز را به جان دربرکشم
هر نغمه و هر چشمه و هر پرنده
هر بَدر ِ کامل و هر پَگاه ِ ديگر
هر قلّه و هر درخت و هر انسان ِ ديگر را.

رخصت ِ زيستن را دست‌بسته دهان‌بسته گذشتم دست و دهان بسته
گذشتيم

و منظر ِ جهان را
تنها
از رخنه‌ی تنگ ‌چشمي‌ حصار ِ شرارت ديديم
...

شاملو

Anonymous said...

OK Payam. But not now and not here. Definately some time in near future,if you are still interested, we will talk.

We may meet on the concerte then Yasi.